如果您无法下载资料,请参考说明:
1、部分资料下载需要金币,请确保您的账户上有足够的金币
2、已购买过的文档,再次下载不重复扣费
3、资料包下载后请先用软件解压,在使用对应软件打开
EmploymentDiscriminationPlaintiffsinFederalCourt:FromBadtoWorse?KevinM.Clermont&StewartJ.Schwab*ThisarticleusesdatafromtheAdministrativeOfficeoftheUnitedStatesCourtstoconveytherealitiesoffederalemploymentdiscriminationlitigation.Litigantsinthese“jobs”casesappealmoreoftenthanotherlitigants,withthedefendantsdoingfarbetteronappealthantheplaintiffs.Thesetroublesomefactsmighthelpexplainwhytodaymanyfewerplaintiffsareundertakingthefrustratingrouteintofederaldistrictcourt,where,relativelyoften,plaintiffsmustpursuetheirclaimsallthewaythroughtrial,andwhere,atbothpretrialandtrial,theseplaintiffslosemoreoftenthanotherfederalplaintiffs.INTRODUCTIONFiveyearsagowesurveyedhowemploymentdiscriminationplaintiffsfaredinfederalcourt.1Wewroteinsummarythattheyhaveatoughrowtohoe.Comparedtootherplaintiffs,theymanagefewerresolutionsearlyinlitigation,andsotheyhavetoproceedtotrialmoreoften.Theywinalowerproportionofcasesduringpretrialandattrial.Then,moreoftheirsuccessfulcasesundergoappeal.Onappeal,theyhaveahardertimebothinupholdingtheirsuccessesandinreversingadverseoutcomes.Thistoughtalewasanimportantstoryforseveralobviousreasons.Forone,employmentdiscriminationcases,theso-calledjobscategory,hadcometoconstituteaverybigfractionofthefederalcivildocket.Suchcasesthenreignedasthelargestsinglecategoryoffederalcivilcases,atnearlytenpercentofthatdocket.*ClermontisFlanaganProfessorofLaw,CornellUniversity;SchwabisAllanR.TesslerDeanandProfessorofLaw,CornellUniversity.TheywouldliketothankJohnDonohue,PeterSiegelman,andNicoleWatersfortheircomments.1KevinM.Clermont&StewartJ.Schwab,HowEmploymentDiscriminationPlaintiffsFareinFederalCourt,1J.EMPIRICALLEGALSTUD.429(2004);seealsoKevinM.Clermontetal.,HowEmployment-DiscriminationPlaintiffsFareintheFederalCourtsofAppeals,7EMPLOYEERTS.&EMP.POL’YJ.547(2003).4HarvardLaw&PolicyReview[Vol.3Inthisarticle,weupdatethetale,againbyusinggovernmentaldatabutnowusingfivemoreyearsofdata.2Thenewdatashowthatthingshaveindeedchangedinemployment